Tuesday, April 1, 2008

I wrote this because I love you...

What's holding you back you man idiot?

In one of the classes we teach at FSU, Creative Strategy 1, our advertising students are working on their final project for White House Black Market. The students are excited but nervous as they'll be presenting to some pretty Senior Level Dudes and Dude-ettes from WHBM. But most of all they are competing against each other. Their final project is to develop creative executions in traditional and non traditional media and provide research and reasoning for their strategy.

We've been meeting with groups hearing their ideas for the past few weeks and the one issue that seems consistent among all of them is a fear to explore wild and far places in their minds. They aren't going far enough with their ideas and their brainstorming sessions, settling for the typical bland messages and images that go with the fashion advertising or stopping with the first few concepts they bump into. They are afraid of getting too out there as it could be too shocking, weird or whatever. They are worried if they present an idea that is too unlike what WHBM always does it will be rejected on the basis that it is simply too different.

We've taken them through the Six Hat process and they know green hat is for ideas not concerns but they can't really help themselves, they are editing themselves before they speak and even before they think.

After our consultations last night it reminded me how hard it can be for people/organizations/groups to really let go. To imagine things that are impossible, ridiculous and silly. I can think of many Six Hat sessions that start off where anything goes and people can't deal with it. They can't let go of their assumptions.

I remember my high school drama teacher's complaint during A MidSummer Night's Dream. I was playing Bottom, and she kept telling me that I wasn't going far enough. What she meant was I wasn't giving her anything to work with, she could rein me in if she needed to but I wasn't giving her anything to work with. She'd say, "you are playing a man idiot who was turned into a donkey by a fairy, What is holding you back?" I kept trying to play Bottom in our world, in my world, the world that has limits, but if you can go to a place that men can be turned into donkeys you allow yourself a certain freedom with your ideas.

You have to have ideas to edit. If you're figuring out how to reach more customers, increase your fundraising efforts or if you're creating a campaign for a tough industry like fashionyou MUST have some extraordinary ideas, some weird ideas and some bizzaro ones too. Pull back later go nuts now. Imagine you're in the world of a man idiot turned into a donkey by a fairy now what are your ideas?

I wrote this because I love you...

3 comments:

Vanessa Mc said...

I can definitely tell that we are all having problems brainstorming for WH|BM. I'm pretty sure we saw every idea that we came up with in one of their previous catalogs. My problem isn't so much that I can't think of outrageous ideas, the reason I hold back is because I feel like I loose credibility when I spit out something that doesn't make sense. I guess the group that learns to get over that fear will be the one that wins.

Kline said...

Jeff,

Although I have nothing to do with White House Black Market, I really appreciate you blogging here ... and about that. I think that your advice is excellent and hopefully helps a group or two solidify their ideas. And to Vanessa, I think that it can be difficult to say what you are thinking, even if it doesn't make sense, but you have to remember the rest of your group. You are a family now and you have to be open with them. You have to realize that no one will like you less if you overstep your boundaries. What is way more important is realizing (or maybe not realizing) how the brain works. What does that mean? Well, if one person says something bazaar, who knows what that could make me think, that would be back in line, but is a great idea.

Let free....

That wasn't the original reason why I was commenting, but I thought it might help.

So back to my original thought of gratitude to Jeff. I really appreciate you blogging here on our blog as well. I that the conversation becomes much more two way when the "elders" get involved. I look at it in a way that the teaching doesn't have to stop in the classroom, and we can get advice and see what you think as well, anytime.

I don't know how many times the CYLers have blogged, but I think it is neat to hear from you guys too. There is so much you all have to offer as well.

You could make an analogy that we were doing this blog while being watched through a two-sided mirror, with little interaction from the other side of the mirror. But when someone opens that door, and steps their feet in here with us. Man, cool posts like this happen.

I just hope everyone gets to read this post before it gets pushed down too far if they are having problems with idea generation.

Tom Laughon said...

I love Jeff. I love creativity. I love our classes and I love America.

I too blieve that being willing to make an Ass of oneself is what it takes to open the flood gates for ideas to flow forth. Genius is in the editing, but we have to have lots of stuff to edit in order to have breakthrough innovative ideas to emerge. Read Luke Sullivans definition of the creative process. Become one with the big or try being Bottom (read Jeff's blog again). Surprise yourself. Surprise your team. Surprise the world. And, by all means, have fun doing all of the above. Rinse and repeat.